Annuities
Why Annuities Exist
Most retirement planning focuses on accumulation — building a nest egg through 401(k)s, IRAs, real estate, and savings. But the real test isn't getting to retirement. It's making your money last through it. Annuities are designed to solve specific retirement problems that other financial products don't address as well:
- How do I protect a portion of my savings from market losses?
- How do I create income I can't outlive?
- How do I grow money tax-deferred without contribution limits?
This page covers three categories of fixed annuities that solve these problems in different ways: Multi-Year Guaranteed Annuities (MYGAs), Growth-Oriented Indexed Annuities, and Income-Oriented Indexed Annuities.
On this page
- Multi-Year Guaranteed Annuities (MYGAs)
- Growth-Oriented Indexed Annuities
- Income-Oriented Indexed Annuities (with Lifetime Income Riders)
- Putting annuities in context
- Common annuity questions
Multi-Year Guaranteed Annuities (MYGAs)
What they are
A MYGA is the simplest form of fixed annuity. You deposit a lump sum, and the insurance company guarantees a fixed interest rate for a specified term — typically 3, 5, 7, or 10 years. At the end of the term, you can renew, take the money, transfer it tax-free to another annuity, or annuitize it for income.
Think of a MYGA as a CD's older, more sophisticated cousin. Same general concept — guaranteed rate for a set term — with two important differences:
- Tax deferral. You don't pay taxes on the interest until you withdraw it. This compounds your growth meaningfully over multi-year periods.
- Generally higher rates than bank CDs of comparable terms, because insurance companies invest differently and have different cost structures.
Who they're for
MYGAs are ideal for the safe portion of a retirement portfolio — money you don't need immediately, can't afford to lose, and want to grow predictably. Common uses:
- Replacing maturing CDs or bonds with a higher-yielding alternative
- Sheltering interest income from current taxation (especially valuable for higher-bracket retirees)
- Creating a “fixed income ladder” with staggered MYGA terms
- Parking proceeds from a home sale, inheritance, or business sale
Strengths
- Guaranteed rate, guaranteed term. No surprises.
- Principal protection. Subject to the claims-paying ability of the issuing carrier, your principal is not at market risk.
- Tax-deferred growth. Interest compounds without annual tax drag.
- Liquidity provisions. Most MYGAs allow penalty-free withdrawals of a portion of the value each year (commonly 10%), and many waive surrender charges for nursing home or terminal illness situations.
- No annual fees in most MYGA contracts.
Trade-offs
- Surrender charges apply if you withdraw beyond the free amount during the guarantee period.
- Liquidity is limited — these aren't checking accounts. Plan around the term.
- Tax-deferred, not tax-free. Withdrawals are taxed as ordinary income, and withdrawals before age 59½ may incur an additional 10% IRS penalty on the gain.
- Rate at renewal isn't guaranteed. When the term ends, you'll be offered a current renewal rate that may be higher or lower than your original.
How to compare MYGAs. The headline rate is only part of the picture. Sophisticated buyers also look at carrier financial strength ratings (A.M. Best, S&P, Moody's), free withdrawal provisions and how they're calculated, market value adjustments (MVAs), the surrender schedule, and the carrier's renewal practices.
Growth-Oriented Indexed Annuities
What they are
Indexed annuities (sometimes called fixed indexed annuities or FIAs) are a hybrid: they offer principal protection like a MYGA, but instead of a fixed interest rate, your interest is calculated based on the performance of a market index — most commonly the S&P 500, but increasingly also custom indices designed for annuity products.
Like an IUL on the life insurance side, indexed annuities feature:
- A floor (typically 0%) — you don't lose money to market declines
- A cap, participation rate, or spread — which limits your upside in exchange for the downside protection
A growth-oriented indexed annuity is designed primarily for accumulation. The objective is to grow the contract value over time, with the eventual goal of taking lump-sum withdrawals, transferring to another vehicle, leaving a legacy, or starting income later.
Who they're for
Growth-oriented indexed annuities suit savers who want:
- Equity-linked upside potential without exposure to market losses
- Tax-deferred growth without IRA/401(k) contribution limits
- A middle path between bonds (low risk, low return) and equities (higher risk, higher return)
- Time horizon flexibility — they're designed for multi-year holding, but with growth-oriented designs you're not locked into a specific income strategy
Strengths
- Principal protection from market downturns
- Index-linked growth with no direct market risk
- Tax deferral — gains compound without annual taxation
- No contribution limits — useful for high earners who've maxed qualified plans
- Multiple crediting strategies within a single contract — you can allocate among different index methods, fixed accounts, and term lengths
Trade-offs
- Capped upside. When markets surge, you don't get the full gain.
- Surrender charges during the surrender period (typically 5–10 years).
- Complexity. Crediting methods, caps, participation rates, and bonus structures vary widely. Reading the contract — and understanding it — matters.
- Carriers can adjust caps and participation rates at the end of each crediting term within contractual minimums.
Common crediting methods
Understanding how interest is credited is essential to understanding what you actually own:
- Annual Point-to-Point — measures the index from the start of the year to the end of the year, applying a cap or participation rate
- Monthly Sum (Monthly Cap) — sums monthly index changes, with each positive month capped and each negative month counted in full; can outperform in steady up markets and underperform in volatile ones
- Monthly Average — averages 12 monthly index values to determine the year's return
- Multi-Year Point-to-Point — measures over a multi-year period (often 2 or 5 years), typically with a higher cap or participation rate
No single method is universally best. The right method depends on the index, the term, and the market environment — which is why most quality indexed annuities let you allocate among multiple methods and reallocate at each term reset.
Income-Oriented Indexed Annuities (with Lifetime Income Riders)
What they are
This is a different animal. An income-oriented indexed annuity is built around a Guaranteed Lifetime Withdrawal Benefit (GLWB) — a rider that provides a contractually guaranteed stream of income for life, regardless of how the underlying contract value performs.
Here's the structure:
- You deposit money into an indexed annuity.
- You add an income rider, which creates a separate income value (sometimes called a benefit base) that grows by a guaranteed roll-up rate during the deferral period.
- At a future date you choose, you “turn on” lifetime income — calculated as a percentage of the income value, with the percentage typically increasing the longer you wait.
- Income continues for your lifetime (or jointly for you and a spouse) even if the contract value runs to zero.
Who they're for
Income-oriented indexed annuities suit retirees and pre-retirees who want:
- Pension-like income they can't outlive
- Protection against longevity risk (the risk of living longer than your money)
- Income certainty to cover essential expenses, regardless of market conditions
- Joint lifetime income with a spouse, ensuring both partners are protected
This product is increasingly important in a world where traditional employer pensions have largely disappeared. For people who don't have a pension, an income annuity can create one.
Strengths
- Guaranteed lifetime income — the carrier is contractually obligated to pay, subject to its claims-paying ability
- Income that can rise with strong underlying performance, while never falling below the guaranteed floor
- Spousal protection — joint income options continue payments to a surviving spouse
- Death benefit — most contracts pay the remaining contract value to beneficiaries if you pass before exhausting the account
- Compounding income value during the deferral period, often at attractive guaranteed rates
Trade-offs
- Rider charges apply annually, typically deducted from the contract value (not the income value)
- The income value isn't a withdrawable account balance. It's used solely to calculate your lifetime income — you can't take it as a lump sum.
- Once income starts, your decisions are largely made. Flexibility decreases.
- Surrender charges apply during the surrender period if you take more than the rider allows.
How the math works (simplified). Imagine you deposit $200,000 and add an income rider with a 7% guaranteed roll-up for up to 10 years. After 10 years of deferral, your income value has grown to roughly $393,000. At age 70, the rider's payout factor for a single life might be 6%. Your guaranteed lifetime income would be $393,000 × 6% = approximately $23,580 per year, for the rest of your life — even if the underlying contract value has earned less. These numbers are illustrative. Actual roll-up rates, payout factors, and contract terms vary by carrier and product. The principle, though, is consistent: the income value drives the income, and the income is guaranteed for life.
Putting annuities in context
Annuities aren't a substitute for the rest of your retirement plan — they're a tool that addresses specific problems other tools don't solve well. A useful framework:
- Money you need now → liquid savings, checking, money market
- Money you need in the next 1–3 years → CDs, short-term bonds, conservative funds
- Money you need in the next 4–10 years for safe growth → MYGAs, growth-oriented indexed annuities
- Money you need to generate guaranteed lifetime income → income-oriented indexed annuities, immediate annuities
- Money you have time to grow aggressively and can afford to lose → equities and other growth investments
The goal isn't to put everything in one place. It's to match each portion of your savings to the job it needs to do.
Common annuity questions
Are annuities safe?
Fixed annuities are backed by the claims-paying ability of the issuing insurance company. State guaranty associations provide an additional layer of protection within statutory limits. Choosing financially strong carriers — and diversifying across carriers when amounts are large — is the standard practice.
Can I lose money?
With fixed and indexed annuities, your principal is protected from market losses. You can lose money to surrender charges if you withdraw early, and rider charges can reduce contract value over time. But the kind of loss you might experience in stocks during a market crash isn't a feature of these products.
How are they taxed?
In a non-qualified annuity (funded with after-tax money), gains are tax-deferred until withdrawal, then taxed as ordinary income. Withdrawals before age 59½ may incur an additional 10% IRS penalty on the gain. In a qualified annuity (inside an IRA, for example), the underlying tax treatment of the IRA applies.
What if I change my mind?
Most annuities have a “free look” period — typically 10 to 30 days after issue — during which you can return the contract for a full refund. Beyond that, surrender charges apply within the surrender period, declining over time until they reach zero.
See how an annuity fits your retirement plan
We'll show you several options across multiple top-rated carriers, explain the trade-offs, and help you decide if an annuity belongs in your strategy.
